Introduction

In an increasingly complex financial landscape, strategic alignment, risk management, and capital optimization have become the cornerstones of success for executive management teams (EMT) in financial institutions. The Kohl Strategic Management Framework (SMF) provides a roadmap for leaders desiring to move their institution forward. The Strategic Pricing Framework (SPF) is a use case focused tactical implementation of the SMF. The SPF is a great example of how the SMF offers financial institutions a comprehensive approach to unify organizational goals, ensure sustainable profitability, and strengthen regulatory alignment.

Demographic and economic shifts, including aging populations, workforce challenges, and technological disruptions, have rendered traditional financial models less effective. Financial institutions now face regionalized economic shifts and rapidly changing consumer behavior, requiring a flexible and data-driven approach. Kohl’s SMF provides the agility and adaptability needed to navigate these transitions while ensuring long-term strategic resilience. This paper explores how the SPF’s core components form the foundation of Kohl’s SMF, driving strategic decision-making and organizational excellence.

Discovering and Creating Value Through Strategic Focus

At the core of Kohl’s SMF is the ability to identify and prioritize the elements that create value while eliminating those that destroy it. By analyzing product lines, business segments, and operational activities, institutions can:

 

  • Pinpoint high-value products, services, or segments that drive profitability.
  • Eliminate or restructure initiatives that erode value.
  • Align marketing and operational resources to focus on value-creating opportunities.
  • Quantify operational improvements using Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing (TDABC).
  • Benchmark against peers to highlight areas for performance improvement and cost savings.

This foundational insight ensures leadership prioritizes initiatives that directly enhance sustainable growth and strategic success. By linking value creation with operational excellence, SMF positions institutions for measurable and lasting improvements.

 Executing the SMF

The Kohl Strategic Pricing Framework (SPF) serves as the operational core of the broader Strategic Management Framework (SMF). Many studies have shown that ~75% of strategies fail, not because the strategy was necessarily bad, but because they fail to execute the strategy. The SPF establishes the pricing boundaries, profitability benchmarks, and risk-adjusted return metrics that fuel SMF’s strategic insights.

  • How SPF Works in Context of SMF:
    • Pricing Alignment: SPF ensures that loan and deposit pricing reflect risk-adjusted returns, feeding directly into SMF’s goal of capital efficiency and ROA sustainability.
    • Profitability Analytics: By evaluating products, segments, and customers, SPF identifies areas of value creation or destruction that SMF uses to drive strategic decisions.
    • Risk Management Integration: SPF’s focus on risk-adjusted returns allows SMF to align strategic decisions with regulatory and capital requirements.
    • Strategic Pricing Boundaries: SPF sets minimum prices for loans and maximum prices for deposits to ensure an ROA that maintains the institution’s capital ratio. For credit unions, this ensures that any excess profitability is funneled back to the membership in the form of potentially better rates.

In essence, SPF provides the granular, operational data that SMF uses to guide executive-level strategy, ensuring every pricing decision aligns with long-term profitability and institutional goals.

Using AI Feature Importance Analysis to Identify True Business Drivers

As financial institutions grow more complex, identifying the true drivers of profitability and risk becomes a significant challenge. Kohl’s Strategic Management Framework leverages AI-driven Feature Importance Analysis to provide executives with deep insights into the internal and external variables that most influence business outcomes. This advanced approach helps financial institutions cut through noise and focus on what truly matters for strategic decision-making.

  • Feature Importance Analysis: AI models, such as gradient boosting, random forests, or deep learning, rank features based on their contribution to predictive accuracy. These features can include metrics like loan performance, customer demographics and behavior, interest rate sensitivities, and operational costs.

 

  • Key Benefits:
    • Prioritization of Resources: Helps executives identify which products, services, or operational processes yield the highest returns or pose the greatest risks.
    • Enhanced Strategic Alignment: Focuses organizational efforts on high-impact areas, ensuring alignment with long-term goals like ROA and capital sustainability.
    • Risk Mitigation: Identifies hidden vulnerabilities within the institution, such as products with high default risks or areas of operational ineffectiveness.

By integrating AI Feature Importance Analysis into the SMF, Kohl enables financial institutions to focus on data-driven strategies that support long-term success. Executives can now base decisions on empirical evidence, reducing reliance on intuition and increasing the likelihood of sustainable growth.

Aligning the Organization with a Common Goal

Kohl’s SMF enables executive leadership to align the organization around a singular, measurable goal: Return on Assets (ROA). By fostering transparency, accountability, and collaboration across silos, SMF ensures that every department and decision contributes to long-term profitability.

  • Key Contributions:
    • Aligns all departmental silos by focusing everyone on the same metric.
    • Drives balanced decisions that align growth, risk, and return.
    • Establishes clear, strategic alignment around ROA as the unifying metric.

The emphasis on ROA ensures that financial institutions prioritize capital-efficient strategies while fostering an enterprise-wide focus on sustainable growth.

SMF’s Foundation in RAROC Principles

Kohl’s SMF builds upon the established principles of Risk-Adjusted Return on Capital (RAROC), combining risk management, profitability analytics, and strategic planning.

 

  • RAROC Foundations:
    • Originated in the 1970s to balance risk and return at Bankers Trust.
    • Provides a methodology for linking pricing decisions to capital efficiency.

SMF expands on RAROC’s core principles, incorporating profitability measures like ROA and ensuring that strategic decisions balance risk-adjusted returns with organizational goals. By linking risk management to pricing strategies, SMF creates a framework for evaluating the long-term sustainability of financial decisions.

SMF as a Strategic Decision-Making Tool: SMART, SWOT, and PESTEL Integration

Kohl’s SMF integrates traditional strategic planning tools like SWOT and PESTEL analysis while incorporating SMART principles to ensure decisions are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound.

  • SWOT Analysis: Identifies internal strengths and weaknesses, as well as external opportunities and threats.
  • PESTEL Analysis: Evaluates macroeconomic factors, including political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal considerations.
  • SMART Objectives: Ensures that the insights derived from SWOT and PESTEL are actionable, measurable, and aligned with strategic priorities.

By combining SPF’s profitability analytics with these strategic tools, Kohl’s SMF enables executive leadership to:

  • Identify emerging risks and opportunities.
  • Align operational decisions with long-term strategic objectives.
  • Foster a forward-looking approach to organizational planning, driven by clear and measurable goals.

Using Neural Networks to Anticipate Balance Changes

Kohl’s SMF incorporates advanced Neural Network models to help financial institutions anticipate balance changes in conjunction with other critical drivers, such as interest rates, economic conditions, and customer behavior. By leveraging Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) or Graph Neural Networks (GNNs), institutions can accurately forecast balance dynamics and improve decision-making.

  • Neural Network Models for Balance Prediction:
    • RNNs are ideal for analyzing sequential data, such as historical account balances and interest rate fluctuations, to forecast future trends.
    • GNNs can incorporate both internal and external relationships, such as customer interactions and macroeconomic indicators, to provide a holistic view of balance changes.
  • Key Drivers Considered:
    • Historical balance trends and seasonality.
    • Sensitivity to interest rate changes and monetary policy shifts.
    • Economic indicators such as unemployment, GDP growth, and inflation.
    • Customer behavior metrics, including deposit patterns and withdrawal tendencies.
  • Strategic Benefits:
    • Enhanced Liquidity Management: Neural networks provide precise forecasts that allow institutions to optimize liquidity strategies and minimize funding costs.
    • Interest Rate Risk Mitigation: By anticipating balance changes under various rate scenarios, institutions can proactively manage exposure to interest rate volatility.
    • Improved Capital Planning: Accurate balance predictions enable better alignment of capital with strategic objectives, ensuring regulatory compliance and operational resilience.
  • Actionable Insights for Executives:
    • AI-powered tools provide clear visualizations of predicted balance changes, enabling executives to understand the impact of different drivers and make informed decisions.
    • Scenario analysis allows leadership to test strategies under varying conditions, ensuring readiness for economic uncertainties.

By incorporating Neural Network models into Kohl’s SMF, financial institutions gain a competitive edge in managing balance dynamics and aligning operational decisions with broader strategic goals.

 

 

Supporting CAMELS Management

Regulatory performance, as measured by the CAMELS framework, is a critical focus for financial institutions. Kohl’s SMF provides executive teams with the insights needed to address each CAMELS component effectively:

  • C: Capital Adequacy
  • A: Asset Quality
  • M: Management Performance
  • E: Earnings Stability
  • L: Liquidity Management
  • S: Sensitivity to Market Risk

Through data-driven analysis, SMF helps institutions proactively manage these areas, improving regulatory ratings and demonstrating strong oversight.

Proactive Regulatory Alignment

Regulators value institutions that demonstrate proactive management and robust control over risks. Kohl’s SMF enables leadership to:

  • Deliver forward-looking, data-driven analytics that anticipate risks. Showcase control over profitability and capital adequacy.
  • Build trust and confidence with regulators through transparency and proactive strategies. This positions management teams as proactive stewards of institutional stability, strengthening relationships with regulators.

Managing Liquidity and Interest Rate Risks

Liquidity and interest rate risk are key considerations for financial institutions. Kohl’s SMF supports risk management by ensuring pricing decisions align with liquidity needs and mitigate exposure to interest rate volatility.

  • Key Contributions:
    • Aligns loan and deposit pricing with liquidity requirements.
    • Balances interest rate risk with profitability objectives.
    • Enhances institutional resilience in volatile market conditions.

 

By managing these risks effectively, institutions can maintain financial stability and strategic flexibility.

Enhancing Operational Efficiency

Kohl’s SMF equips operations teams with tools and insights that enhance efficiency and cost management across the institution. By leveraging profitability data and operational benchmarks, institutions can:

  • Identify process inefficiencies and prioritize areas for improvement.
  • Use Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing (TDABC) to measure operational costs accurately and allocate resources effectively.
  • Benchmark performance against industry peers to highlight gaps and drive targeted enhancements. Improve workflows by aligning operations with profitability insights, ensuring every process contributes to overall financial success.

Through these measures, SMF empowers operations teams to deliver measurable increases in effectiveness through cost reductions, improved productivity, and streamlined processes.

Measuring Marketing ROI

Kohl’s SMF empowers marketing teams to evaluate and optimize the Return on Investment (ROI) of marketing initiatives using Marginal Economic Contribution (MEC). By integrating MEC into the decision-making process, institutions can measure the long-term value created by each campaign or product.

  • Pre-Launch Evaluation: SMF enables marketing teams to determine the projected MEC for an initiative before its launch, assessing whether it aligns with institutional goals and profitability thresholds.
  • Minimum Volume for Break-Even: Marketing teams can calculate the minimum volume needed for a campaign to break even, ensuring resources are allocated efficiently and strategically.
  • Performance Measurement: By isolating the MEC, institutions gain clear insights into the incremental contribution of marketing efforts to the institution’s Economic Value of Equity (EVE).
  • Strategic Alignment: Marketing initiatives are aligned with SMF objectives, ensuring they contribute to long-term ROA sustainability and overall profitability.

 

With these insights, marketing teams can make data-driven decisions, optimize campaigns, and focus resources on initiatives that create measurable and sustainable value. SMF provides the tools to evaluate past performance, improve future strategies, and align marketing activities with the institution’s overarching financial goals.

Aligning Human Resources

Kohl’s SMF provides Human Resource (HR) teams with a data-driven framework to align personnel resources with the institution’s strategic goals. By integrating insights from the SMF, HR can ensure that staffing levels, workforce capabilities, and organizational priorities are optimized to support long-term profitability and operational excellence.

  • Aligning Personnel to Strategic Goals: HR can use the SMF to identify the roles and skills required to achieve the institution’s strategic objectives, such as Return on Assets (ROA) targets, profitability benchmarks, and capital efficiency.
  • Identifying Excess Capacity: By evaluating resource utilization across departments, the SMF can help HR pinpoint areas of overcapacity where staffing levels may exceed actual demand. This enables leadership to redeploy personnel to higher-value activities or reduce costs through workforce adjustments.
  • Addressing Capacity Shortfalls: The SMF highlights areas where capacity shortfalls exist, enabling HR to identify gaps in personnel or skills. This ensures that staffing plans align with projected workloads and operational requirements.
  • Workforce Planning and Development: Using insights from the SMF, HR can develop targeted training and recruitment initiatives to build workforce capabilities that align with the institution’s evolving strategic priorities.
  • Measuring Human Capital ROI: The SMF allows HR to assess the contribution of personnel investments to organizational profitability and performance, ensuring that staffing decisions generate measurable value.

By aligning human resources with strategic objectives, Kohl’s SMF ensures that the institution has the right people in the right roles at the right time. This alignment fosters greater efficiency, enhances workforce productivity, and supports the institution’s long-term growth and resilience.

Conclusion: Kohl’s SMF as a Strategic Enabler

Kohl’s Strategic Management Framework (SMF) provides financial institutions with a comprehensive approach to align goals, manage risks, and enhance profitability. Rooted in RAROC principles, the framework integrates strategic tools like SWOT, PESTEL, and TDABC to support decision-making and operational excellence.

Key Benefits:

  • Aligns the organization around ROA and long-term capital goals.
  • Enhances regulatory confidence and CAMELS performance.
  • Drives operational effectiveness and strategic marketing focus.
  • Manages liquidity and interest rate risks.
  • Empowers executives with AI-driven insights to identify true business drivers.
  • Anticipates balance changes with Neural Network-based forecasting models.

By adopting Kohl’s SMF, executive leadership can position their institutions for sustainable success in an ever-changing financial landscape.

Kohl Analytics Group - Copyright 2019, 2025 - All Rights Reserved